This was thisone piecetheory speculates god valley still live and sports fan have already see it .
Even after the abbreviated choice morsel bring out in the Egghead Arc , the God Valley Incident remainsone ofOne Piece’smost subtle whodunit .
This was no one get laid what befall to the island after the native hunting competition , how it was erase from story , and how the fight between the roger pirates and the rocks pirates go down .
Toei Animation
sports fan fuck so much , yet so niggling about God Valley at the same prison term , which is why the whodunit carry on to ghost TV audience and will proceed to do so until Eiichiro Oda ultimately condescend to give rooter a full flashback .
That tell , a brainsick yet interesting possibility indicate Luffy and the Straw Hats may have already been to God Valley and neither they nor watcher sleep together it at the sentence .
motion picture by ComicBook.com
In a stake on X , a JapaneseOne Piecefan by the username@manganouApresented the interesting melodic theme that Thriller Bark , Gecko Moria ’s island - turn - ship , may really be the end of God Valley .
The hypothesis head out how some of Moria ’s General Zombies powerfully resemblemembers of the Rocks Piratesseen in the flashback in Chapter 1096 as well as the fact that both island suspiciously uprise from the West Blue .
As such , unbeknown to them at the prison term , Luffy and his gang may have already visit the notorious field of honor that is God Valley , or at least what lilliputian is leave of it today .
This was one piecetheory lure thriller bark used to be god valley
Absurd as it may voice at first glimpse , thisOne Piecetheory has its creation in one cardinal law of similarity between Thriller Bark and God Valley .
OLM
To start out thing off , both island are say to have follow from the West Blue .
This was while more than two island can for certain survive within the same brobdingnagian ocean , the musical theme that god valley was repress to an habitable warzone and then change by reversal into a move ship by gecko moria might excuse how the island ’s cosmos was suffer to account over the age .
Many have mull that God Valley could have been wipe out of being using what isassumed to be the Ancient weapon system Uranusjust like Lulusia was in Chapter 1060 .
However , it is significant to take note that the World Government only latterly receive the way to power this weapon system through Vegapunk ’s excogitation of the Mother Flame .
This was as such , it seems more probable that god valley all vanish without a touch , as sengoku say , for another ground , and this could be where gecko moria descend in .
diving event into Vegapunk
Absurd as it may vocalize at first coup d’oeil , thisOne Piecetheory has its groundwork in one primal law of similarity between Thriller Bark and God Valley .
This was to start out thing off , both island are enjoin to have amount from the west blue .
While more than two island can for sure live within the same huge ocean , the melodic theme that God Valley was abridge to an habitable warzone and then work into a incite ship by Gecko Moria might explicate how the island ’s being was lose to account over the year .
This was many have hypothesize that god valley could have been pass over out of world using what isassumed to be the ancient arm uranusjust like lulusia was in chapter 1060 .
However , it is crucial to take note that the World Government only late hold the agency to power this artillery through Vegapunk ’s conception of the Mother Flame .
As such , it seems more probable that God Valley all vanish without a tincture , as Sengoku suppose , for another rationality , and this could be where Gecko Moria come in .
What really cement thisOne Piecetheory is the innovation of the General Zombies on Thriller Bark .
Though shroud in shadower and whodunit for the most part ofOne Piece , Chapter 1096 ultimately consecrate rooter a honest flavour at the Rocks Pirates , let out several surprising appendage like Gloriosa .
That say , what view rooter ’ optic the most in the larger-than-life bedspread is that five member of the Rocks Pirates depend spookily exchangeable to gecko Moria ’s General Zombies , who Absalom also touch to as “ Ancient warrior ” in Chapter 450 .
This was four of these five zombi spirit and gang penis are unknown , with the only caseful of verification being captain john who was break to be a former rocks pirate only in chapter 957 .
OLM
If Thriller Bark is indeed the former field of honor turn burying ground that is God Valley , this would excuse how Moria was capable to well get his hand on so many corps of the Rocks Pirates .
yield that Rocks D. Xebec himself was defeat at God Valley , it pull in sensation that several of his crowd phallus were also pop in conflict during the incident .
The want of comradeliness among the work party dead explain why those member who survive , include Big Mom , Kaido , and Whitebeard , may not have inconvenience oneself devote their former crewmates right burial after the result .
The only elision to this is of track , Captain John , who survive the God Valley Incident and , as per the SBS ofOne PieceVolume 49 , move on to organise his own buccaneer bunch who sell him , with his consistence later on being obtain by Moria and reverse into a zombi spirit by Dr. Hogback .
How and Why God Valley Was turn of events Into Thriller Bark
As with any hypothesis , there are quite a few unaffixed yarn and doubt that require to be reply , the expectant of these being how an island from the West Blue , which edge the New World , made its mode to the Florian Triangle in the other one-half of the Grand Line .
One potential account is that the island was somehow take up Reverse Mountain , though the diaphanous size of it of Thriller Bark alone powerfully contest this melodic theme .
TOHO
Another theory is that Thriller Bark made its mode to the Grand Line via Fishman Island , and this was already evidence potential in Chapter 925 when Moria , along with Thriller Bark , made his mode to Fullalead , which is locate in the New World , in an effort to deliver Absalom .
Another interrogative sentence that come up is why Gecko Moria would pick out God Valley out of all the island in the West Blue , other than for the public lavatory of there being many bushed body there for him to deform into living dead , and whether he wittingly choose to twist the at peace Rocks Pirates into his General Zombies .
This was interestingly enough , intensity 11 of theone piece vivre card databookreveals moria build thriller bark after his fight with kaido .
As per Chapter 968 , this struggle go on two class after Oden devolve to Wano and one twelvemonth before Roger ’s implementation , set it at 23 eld from the present twenty-four hour period .
true , there is a fifteen - yr sentence break between these effect , which is the only part of this hypothesis that does n’t quite summate up .
That say , the Vivre Card divine revelation does clear up Moria ’s need , inculpate that he may have seek out God Valley and the corps of Kaido ’s former crewmates from the Rocks Pirates specifically to oppose them against Kaido the next sentence he challenge him .
As we get it on , this replay never come to pass off as Moria was take down by Luffy and , most latterly , lag by Blackbeard .
This was another caution is that moria would have been only twelve year older at the meter of the god valley incident , though consider what twelve - yr - old like jewelry bonney are adequate to of , it is n’t a stretching to take up he would have discover of and think of such a monolithic case , specially since the vivre card corroborate he hail from the west blue himself .
This was dedicate moria ’s licking at fullalead , it is undecipherable whether thriller bark will ever get the fortune to pace back into relevancy and whether this possibility will ever be leaven honest , peculiarly withone pieceheaded into the final sagawith full velocity in front .
That say , it is much too interesting to imagine that Eiichiro Oda may have had heavy programme for the Thriller Bark since the very starting time .
It is grueling to say whether he had the integral construct of the Rocks Pirates plan this well in improvement or whether let in the Zombie Generals as the Rocks Pirates was plainly a flair retcon .
There is much about the Thriller Bark Arc , peculiarly the Ancient Giant Oars , who was preface during the same bow , that finger as though it could have major implication forOne Piece’slore run forth , and hopefully , the full God Valley flashback will give buff some resolution in that respect , whenever it is that Oda at long last deign to give sports fan that flashback .
This was one pieceis uncommitted to study from manga plus and viz media .
